It is no secret that charities’ traditional sources of income are becoming ever-less predictable, whether public donations, legacies, trust and foundations, or contracts with public bodies such as local authorities, central government or the NHS.
In a world where nothing can be guaranteed, many trustees and charity managers are looking for a more stable source of income, and for an increasing number, trading is being considered. This could be seen as a way of improving a charity’s financial and operational sustainability through diversification, reaching new audiences, or utilising underused skills or resources within the charity itself.
There are a number of questions which any charity considering trading needs to ask itself. It is important not to treat trading income as an end in itself, but rather a chance to solve a strategic problem, open up an opportunity, or boost the charity’s ability to fulfil its charitable objectives.
What do we mean by trading?
Technically all charities are ‘trading’, but the type of trading varies – it is in fact defined in the Charities Act as being one of three things:
· Primary Purpose Trading: normal day-to-day activities which directly further the charity’s purposes – this would include contracts with public bodies.
· Ancillary Primary Purpose Trading: generating income through work completed by the charity’s beneficiaries, or activities which run alongside, but which are not entirely, charitable activities – running a café which can only be accessed by those using the charity’s facilities, for example.
· Non-Primary Purpose Trading: undertaking fundraising activities which are completely unconnected to the activities of the charity
Traditionally trading is considered to be selling goods or operating a shop however it can also be charging for services being provided which are not funded by contracts, training, consulting and fundraising activities.
Sometimes activities can fall into more than one of these categories (for example a café which is open to the general public as well as those using the charity’s facilities), and in these cases the income generated would need to be split accordingly. Whether or not this is the case, it is important to assess which category any proposed trading activity falls into, as they are treated differently for charity tax and accounting purposes and may be subject to tax exemptions.
How does trading impact our charitable purpose?
As with any strategic decision, the mission of the charity should be considered, in the context of how the proposed trading activity will impact it, either positively or negatively. Ideally the trading activity will have a clear connection to the charitable purposes and strategic priorities.
The second consideration is the market: is there a need for the service being proposed, and are there already others offering the same or similar? Will the trading activity create a public benefit?
Equally important is whether the charity has the right skills and capacity to deliver the trading activity. That includes leadership, people, systems, operational capacity and commercial expertise.
Of course, there is the financial question. Any trading activity should come with a sound business and financial plan, so that trustees can understand whether the activity will have a positive or negative financial impact. A negative impact doesn’t necessarily mean the plan is misguided – sometimes charities choose to have a loss leader if that enables them to engage with a new audience. In this case procedures must be in place to safeguard the charity’s financial position.
Even if a trading activity is predicted to deliver a surplus, it may not be the best use of the organisation’s resources, especially if it distracts attention away from the core charitable purpose.
Finally, the question of brand and reputational risk need to be considered – how will the proposed trading activities be viewed by current funders, the general public, and by regulators?
Financial, legal and tax considerations
Primary purpose trading and ancillary primary purpose trading is generally exempt from Corporation Tax, on the presumption that all surpluses generated are returned to the charity. However, non-primary purpose trading is generally taxable as it falls outside the charitable objectives, as defined in the charity’s governing document.
Although this means that such trading surpluses are liable to Corporation Tax, a certain level of trading income is exempt, depending on the total income of the charity (although if you exceed these limits, the entire trading income becomes liable). There are further exemptions including the sale of donated goods, property rental income and certain fundraising events and activities. Tax planning should also form part of the business planning rather than an afterthought.
When it comes to VAT, the rules do not distinguish between charitable and non-charitable trading, so it is important for all charities to undertake a regular VAT review to understand the VAT status of its sources of income.
There are also legal considerations to be taken into account, especially whether the proposed trading activity is allowed under the charity’s Trust Deed or Mem & Arts, or the CIO Foundation document. Changing these to allow specific trading activity will require Charity Commission approval. Any trading activity will also need to comply with appropriate employment, data protection, licensing and sector specific legislation.
Should you set up a trading subsidiary?
If the proposed trading activity is non-primary purpose, likely to expose the charity to tax or VAT registration, or has an increased risk, then it is worth considering whether to establish a separate trading subsidiary.
The advantages of doing this include enabling the charity to separate the commercial trading operations, protect the assets of the charity, and allowing the profits to be generated without exposure to Corporation tax if they are donated in full to the charity. It may also avoid the need for the charity itself to become VAT registered.
However, bear in mind that setting up a trading subsidiary complicates the charity’s structure, lessens direct control over the trading activity, and potentially duplicates management infrastructure. Also, trading subsidiaries may not be able to apply the same VAT and tax emptions that the charity itself is able to do.
Remember too that a subsidiary is not an automatic ‘ring-fence’; the charity’s relationship with it must still be carefully governed.
Governance and risk management
If trustees decide that a trading subsidiary is needed, or if the charity wants to partner with a commercial operator to undertake the trading activity, the same governance and risk management considerations should be applied as those necessary at charity level.
In particular, trustees should consider:
Conflicts of interest: identify, declare and manage them
Capital at risk: define the amount the charity is prepared to invest or expose
Guarantees and intra-group funding: understand exactly what the charity is committing
Brand and reputation: agree escalation routes and non-negotiable standards
Management information: trustees should receive timely reporting against agreed financial and non-financial measures
Exit: decide in advance what would trigger a review, restructure or closure
These are the kind of considerations which trustees will often make when faced with any strategic decision, so they shouldn’t be intimidating or off-putting. In a world where traditional incomes are becoming more uncertain, trading can help maintain the financial sustainability of a charity, as well as opening up new opportunities to meet the organisation’s charitable objectives.
